Cigar Outlet Review: I Went Looking for the Catch in 50%-Off Premium Cigars.

Sales are underway for the first CBD drug approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. The drug, Epidiolex, treats two rare types of epilepsy and is made from marijuana plants grown in the United Kingdom. The maker of the …

What Cigar Outlet is

It is a discount retailer for premium, hand-rolled cigars, built around one promise: brand-name boxes and singles at a guaranteed fifty percent off MSRP or more. Not house blends, not mystery bundles, but the actual labels you would see behind the counter at a good shop, sold for roughly half of what that counter charges. The whole site is organized around that idea, from the standing discount to a clearance section where the markdowns run far deeper.

The prices, and whether they hold up

The headline is the fifty-percent-off-MSRP guarantee, and on the boxes I checked it was honest. I priced a handful of well-known sticks against the big mainstream retailers before ordering, and Cigar Outlet came in lower every time, usually by close to half and occasionally more. The clearance shelf is where it gets a little absurd: I saw discounts in the seventy-percent range on overstock and discontinued sizes. If you are flexible about exactly which vitola you smoke, that is where the real money is.

My worry going in was authenticity, because counterfeit cigars are a genuine problem online and a too-good price is the classic bait. What showed up were sealed, properly boxed, correctly banded cigars that smoked the way those brands are supposed to. This is not a bin of dried-out factory rejects. It reads like legitimate overstock and volume buying passed along as a discount, which is the only version of "cheap premium cigars" worth trusting.

The brands are the real thing

This is what separates it from the no-name bundle sites. The catalog leans on recognizable makers, Montecristo, Macanudo, Romeo y Julieta, Oliva, CAO, the names a cigar smoker already knows and has opinions about. You are not gambling on an unknown blend to save a few dollars. You are buying the same cigar you would pay full price for elsewhere, for less.

Samplers are the smart way in

If you are not ready to commit to a full box, the samplers are the move, and they are where the discount does its best work. A sampler at this pricing lets you run through several brands and sizes for the cost of a few full-price singles, which is the cheapest way I know to figure out what you actually like before buying twenty-five of them. I would point a newcomer at a sampler before anything else on the site.

More than sticks

There is the usual supporting cast too: humidors to keep a growing collection in shape, and the accessories, cutters and the rest, that you end up needing anyway. None of it is the reason to visit, but it means a first order can cover the cigars and the gear to store them in a single shipment.

How the ordering went

The experience is straightforward rather than fancy. Checkout is the standard online-store flow, the cigars shipped promptly, and they arrived packed properly rather than rattling loose in a box. For something as fragile as a cigar, packed-right and shipped-quick is most of what matters, and both held up across the orders I placed. If a shop has ever mailed you cracked wrappers, the difference lands the moment you open the box.

Where it could be better

This is a discounter and it feels like one, in the good sense and the slightly-less-good sense. The site is built to move inventory, not to romance you, so it helps to arrive knowing roughly what you want rather than expecting a guided tour. Stock on the deepest clearance deals rotates, so a steal you bookmark may be gone next week. And because the savings come from overstock and volume, the very best prices cluster on specific sizes rather than every cigar in a line. None of that is a real knock. It is the trade you make for paying half price.

The verdict

I came to Cigar Outlet assuming the discount hid a catch, and the honest answer is that it does not. The brands are real, the boxes arrive right, and the fifty-percent-off-MSRP floor is not marketing math. If you smoke premium cigars and you are tired of paying retail, it is an easy recommendation, especially if you start with a sampler and keep an eye on the clearance page. For anyone who enjoys a good cigar alongside everything else we cover here, a few minutes on cigaroutlet.com is worth it, if only to see how much you have been overpaying.